People Become Less Likely To Contribute To A Virtual Public Good If They Know Many Others Are Already Doing It

People Become Less Likely To Contribute To A Virtual Public Good If They Know Many Others Are Already Doing It
Waze depends on users to voluntarily upload information about traffic accidents and road closures. Linda Davidson/The Washington Post via Getty Images

While people tend to contribute more to a virtual public good if they see others doing the same, this effect reverses if they become aware too many people are participating, according to research that I conducted over the summer. Public goods are things that many people share. They can be physical, such as highways, clean air and blood banks, or virtual, like a free online encyclopedia or mobile traffic app.

Combining methods from geography, urban planning and big-data analysis, my co-authors and I studied millions of postings by users of a mobile navigation app called Waze, in which users voluntarily post traffic-related updates and road conditions in real time. All users of the app benefit as more of them freely contribute information about traffic accidents and road closures. Economists describe this as contributing to a public good.

We found that displaying the “density” of users’ activities on Waze – that is, real time information on how many people are on the app in one’s geographic location – can encourage participation from others in the area, just as it does in the real world. If you see a lot of people donating blood in your local neighborhood or many parents volunteering in your local school, it may motivate you to do the same.

But we also found evidence of a strong “bystander effect” that reverses this after a certain threshold is reached. The bystander effect refers to the phenomenon that an individual’s likelihood of engaging in a helpful act decreases when bystanders are present in a critical situation. Paradoxically, our motivation to contribute to a public good could also decline when we see others doing something. For example, if you saw a lot of people donating blood, you may decide that they don’t need your blood too.

The idea is that people perceive less urgency or motivation to help others when others are present, akin to a diffusion of responsibility.

Why it matters

With more public goods moving online – for example, in-person pledge drives seeking charitable donations now happen through crowdfunding websites such as Kiva or GoFundMe – it’s important to study how the motivations and behaviors of people change in a virtual setting.

Users’ motivation to contribute to public goods in the physical world depends on what is termed “impure altruism,” also known by economists as “warm glow giving.” That is, participation is heavily influenced by an individual’s motives for public recognition.

My research shows that the same effects that happen in real life also seem to occur virtually, suggesting these online spaces should be designed in ways to overcome the bystander effect to encourage more participation. This can be done, for example, by offering nonmonetary rewards for participation such as virtual badges or making it feel like a game.

What other research is being done

Other researchers are also looking into how to influence the behavior of people in virtual spaces.

Some scholars suggest, for example, that participants in primarily digital environments need digital nudges and interventions to enhance a sense of community and create a shared sense of social self on these digital spaces. Studies from social question-and-answer sites in China seem to suggest that commitment toward the site, a shared language and shared vision seem to foster a sense of participation.

Other studies suggest that rather than viewing such online public good platforms in terms of the immediate needs of an information seeker, these platforms should be designed for their long-lasting value to a community of users.The Conversation

About The Author

Anjana Susarla, Omura-Saxena Professor of Responsible AI, Michigan State University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

s

More Articles By This Author

You May Also Like

AVAILABLE LANGUAGES

enafarzh-CNzh-TWdanltlfifrdeeliwhihuiditjakomsnofaplptroruesswsvthtrukurvi

INNERSELF VOICES

fourth july2
It Didn't Have To Be This Way
by Robert Jennings, Innerself.com
There have been some standout successes for some countries dealing with this Covid pandemic.
small yellow bird standing on a big bird feather
The Blessings of the Entire Nature Kingdom
by Marie T. Russell, InnerSelf.com
We are so blessed to live on Planet Earth, yet we tend to take so much of what is here for granted.…
Photo: Sunset over Stonehenge on January 21, 2022, by Stonehenge Dronescapes
Horoscope: Week of January 24 - 30, 2022
by Pam Younghans
This weekly astrological journal is based on planetary influences, and offers perspectives and…
a pocket watch semi-buried in the sand
"I'll Do It Tomorrow" -- The Quicksand of Procrastination
by Jude Bijou
Almost everyone procrastinates. We usually do it to avoid a task that's unpleasant or daunting.…
a green frog sitting on a branch
Playing with Metaphors to Help You With Transformation
by Carl Greer PhD, PsyD
When your story isn’t working for you, when it seems to be influencing what you’re experiencing and…
a woman under a full moon holding a full hourglass
How To Live In Perfect Harmony
by Marie T. Russell, InnerSelf.com
The word harmony has various meanings. It is used in music, in relationships, referring to inner…
full moon over bare trees
Horoscope: Week of January 17 - 23, 2022
by Pam Younghans
This weekly astrological journal is based on planetary influences, and offers perspectives and…
01 15 cast normal to the gutter
Cast Normal to the Gutter: North Node in Taurus
by Sarah Varcas
The Taurus North Node affirms it is time to lay the physical foundations of the new world as the…
From Little to Big: What Would Be Good For Us To Expand?
From Little to Big: What Would Be Good For Us To Expand?
by Marie T. Russell
What would be good for us to expand? Our caring heart would be a great place to start. We can start…
Raise Your Vibes and Bring Light Back to Your World
Raise Your Vibes and Bring Light Back to Your World
by Athena Bahri
There are events in life that change the course of how we interact with others, view ourselves,…
Living the Path of Enlightenment Day by Day
Living the Path of Enlightenment, Day by Day
by Nora Caron
Great prophets, gurus, spiritual leaders, and teachers across the world encourage us to search for…

Selected for InnerSelf Magazine

MOST READ

rooster flapping his wings and "strutting his stuff"
Unpacking the Man Box: How to Face Your “Stuff”
by Ray Arata
All it takes is turning on the news, reading the newspaper, or talking to people these days to be…
critical care in america
American Healthcare vs The World
by Robert Jennings, Innerself.com
Millions of Americans have no health insurance and even if the do they live in fear that one…
small yellow bird standing on a big bird feather
The Blessings of the Entire Nature Kingdom
by Marie T. Russell, InnerSelf.com
We are so blessed to live on Planet Earth, yet we tend to take so much of what is here for granted.…
woman looking out a door through a "curtain" or icicles
Everybody Hurts Sometimes (Video)
by Joyce Vissell
Do you ever find yourself looking at certain people and thinking to yourself, "Surely that person's…
rooster flapping his wings and "strutting his stuff"
Unpacking the Man Box: How to Face Your “Stuff” (Video)
by Ray Arata
All it takes is turning on the news, reading the newspaper, or talking to people these days to be…
a woman under a full moon holding a full hourglass
How To Live In Perfect Harmony (Video)
by Marie T. Russell, InnerSelf.com
The word harmony has various meanings. It is used in music, in relationships, referring to inner…
dont look up2
‘Don’t Look Up’ Illustrates 5 Myths That Fuel Rejection of Science
by Gale Sinatra, University of Southern California and Barbara K. Hofer, Middlebury
Every disaster movie seems to open with a scientist being ignored. “Don’t Look Up” is no exception…
woman laying in a single bed with a full moon in the background
The Subconscious Mind Is Your Creative Co-Conspirator
by Evelyn C. Rysdyk
The subconscious can be creative when you are sleeping. You can program your subconscious before…

New Attitudes - New Possibilities

InnerSelf.comClimateImpactNews.com | InnerPower.net
MightyNatural.com | WholisticPolitics.com | InnerSelf Market
Copyright ©1985 - 2021 InnerSelf Publications. All Rights Reserved.