Pregnant Women Shouldn't Have To Choose Between A Job And A Healthy Baby


Pregnant Women Shouldn't Have To Choose Between A Job And A Healthy BabyEmployers are required to accommodate the needs of pregnant women only in limited circumstances. FotoAndalucia /

Pregnant women in low-income work often face an unappealing choice: lose their job or perform duties that endanger their health and that of their baby.

Walmart, the biggest private employer in the U.S., is a case in point. In 2007, the retailer fired Heather Wiseman for carrying around a bottle of water – despite a doctor’s note saying it was necessary for her pregnancy. A decade later Walmart forced Whitney Tomlinson to take unpaid leave after she revealed her pregnancy-related lifting restrictions.

These aren’t isolated cases. A 2018 New York Times investigation found that some of the largest American companies – including Walmart, AT&T, Merck and Whole Foods – “systematically sideline pregnant women,” “pass them over for promotions and raises” and “fire them when they complain.”

In 2012, I wrote a law review article that explored the ways employers refuse to provide simple accommodations to low-income pregnant workers, such as letting them drink from a water bottle or having co-workers help with heavy lifting. Since then, 18 states have passed laws that require employers to provide pregnancy accommodations, bringing the total to almost two dozen.

But as The New York Times report shows, more needs to be done to ensure women don’t have to make a choice between the health of their babies and earning an income.

A right to accommodation

Recent research suggests that pregnancy discrimination is particularly problematic for low-income women.

While the difference in employment rates between pregnant and nonpregnant women who earn US$20,000 a year or more is relatively small, the gap is more than 11 percentage points among poorer women. And the data already exclude women who have voluntarily exited the workforce, meaning they focus on the more than 60 percent of pregnant women who depend on a paycheck to support their growing families.

Congress passed the Pregnancy Discrimination Act in 1978 to prevent such discrimination. Unfortunately, it hasn’t resolved the problem because, unlike its counterpart, the Americans with Disabilities Act, it does not provide an absolute right to workplace accommodations. Instead, it directs employers to treat pregnant workers the same as similar colleagues.

But since pregnant workers have special concerns – such as a need for easy access to water, lifting restrictions or maternity-fit uniforms – discrimination claims tend to fail because they cannot find a comparable nonpregnant coworker who needs the same accommodation.

States lead the charge

In recent years, states have been filling this gap by passing statutes that provide pregnant workers with an absolute right to workplace accommodations.

The number of states with such laws has almost doubled from just 12 in 2014 to 23 today. And Kentucky is on course to becoming the 24th after its Senate passed an accommodation bill in February.

In addition, in 2015, the Supreme Court, in Young v. UPS, clarified the kind of employer accommodation policy that would violate the Pregnancy Discrimination Act. Specifically, it ruled that an employer that provides pregnant workers less generous accommodations than nonpregnant workers violates the act if it imposes a significant burden without a “sufficiently strong” nondiscriminatory reason.

In other words, an employer can’t simply claim that accommodating a pregnant worker is more expensive or less convenient.

Pregnant Women Shouldn't Have To Choose Between A Job And A Healthy BabyPeggy Young lost her UPS job because she became pregnant in a case that went all the way to the Supreme Court. AP Photo/Susan Walsh

Limited impact

While this caused a spike in the number of claims filed with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the Young decision’s vagueness limited its positive impact.

The number of pregnancy accommodation complaints rose dramatically from just 15 in 2013 to 676 in 2017.

But the Supreme Court didn’t explain what it meant by a “sufficiently strong” reason, allowing employers to continue to argue that accommodating other workers does not trigger an obligation to provide pregnancy accommodations.

In October, a federal district court accepted this argument, ruling that Young allowed an employer to reject a pregnant worker’s request for a lifting accommodation even though the employer had provided that same arrangement to other employees. The reason it gave was that the accommodated workers had been injured on the job.

And now employers are arguing that they shouldn’t have to provide pregnant workers with the same accommodations they offer employees under the Americans with Disabilities Act, which would make it even harder to file a successful claim.

Two solutions

So what’s to be done?

One option is passing a new federal law that requires all employers across the U.S. to provide reasonable accommodations to pregnant women. The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, for example, would do just that. It is nearly identical to many of the recently enacted state statutes, except that it would exempt companies with fewer than 15 employees.

Although it’s been introduced in every Congress since 2012, it has yet to get a hearing. This could change in the current Congress, which has a record number of women.

There’s another option, however: Extend the American with Disabilities Act so that it covers the physical limitations that accompany a healthy pregnancy. Congress broadened the act in 2008 to cover pregnant workers with certain medical conditions like gestational diabetes and pregnancy-induced high blood pressure. Extending it further would require only a small change.

One major objection to this approach, of course, is that the word “disability” connotes a lack of work capacity, a stigma that may harm not only currently pregnant workers but women overall. But this assumption misunderstands the American with Disabilities Act, which differs significantly from earlier disability laws that viewed such people as defective.

Just as the act reshaped the workplace to accommodate disabled people who were previously excluded, it can do the same for pregnant women, recognizing them as legitimate wage earners. There’s no stigma in that.The Conversation

About The Author

Jeannette Cox, Professor of Law, University of Dayton

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Related Books:

The Working Woman's Handbook: Ideas, Insights, and Inspiration for a Successful Creative Career

healthAuthor: Phoebe Lovatt
Binding: Hardcover
Studio: Prestel
Label: Prestel
Publisher: Prestel
Manufacturer: Prestel

Buy Now
Editorial Review: Want to have an exciting, custom-built career? The Working Woman’s Handbook can help you create it. It’s the ultimate guide to job satisfaction, filled with practical advice on developing and driving a working life you love. Bursting with actionable tips, this book outlines an agenda for making and managing money, setting goals, and establishing success-oriented routines, with worksheets, exercises, and fool-proof "how-to" sections to help chart your course. From the lowdown on launching your own venture to a bullet-point checklist for an essential self-care regime, it will teach you to manage any dilemmas that crop up, and take the stress out of setting a budget.

This no-nonsense manual comes packed with author Phoebe Lovatt’s personal insights from her own career as a successful freelance journalist, moderator, and founder of The WW Club, the leading digital resource and global community for working women worldwide. It also includes words of wisdom from various creatives and industry leaders, such as Teen Vogue editor Elaine Welteroth, WAH Nails founder Sharmadean Reid, The Gentlewoman's Editor-in-Chief Penny Martin, and rising fashion designer Sandy Liang.

Whether a first-time freelancer, budding businesswoman, or dedicated professional looking to enhance your prospects, The Working Woman’s Handbook is a go-to career and lifestyle guide for ambitious young women everywhere.

What Works for Women at Work: Four Patterns Working Women Need to Know

healthAuthor: Joan C. Williams
Binding: Paperback
  • Anne-Marie Slaughter

Studio: NYU Press
Label: NYU Press
Publisher: NYU Press
Manufacturer: NYU Press

Buy Now
Editorial Review:
Up-beat, pragmatic, and chock full of advice, What Works for Women at Work is an indispensable guide for working women.
An essential resource for any working woman, What Works for Women at Work is a comprehensive and insightful guide for mastering office politics as a woman. Authored by Joan C. Williams, one of the nation’s most-cited experts on women and work, and her daughter, writer Rachel Dempsey, this unique book offers a multi-generational perspective into the realities of today’s workplace. Often women receive messages that they have only themselves to blame for failing to get ahead—Negotiate more! Stop being such a wimp! Stop being such a witch! What Works for Women at Work tells women it’s not their fault. The simple fact is that office politics often benefits men over women. Based on interviews with 127 successful working women, over half of them women of color, What Works for Women at Work presents a toolkit for getting ahead in today’s workplace. Distilling over 35 years of research, Williams and Dempsey offer four crisp patterns that affect working women: Prove-It-Again!, the Tightrope, the Maternal Wall, and the Tug of War. Each represents different challenges and requires different strategies—which is why women need to be savvier than men to survive and thrive in high-powered careers. Williams and Dempsey’s analysis of working women is nuanced and in-depth, going far beyond the traditional cookie-cutter, one-size-fits-all approaches of most career guides for women. Throughout the book, they weave real-life anecdotes from the women they interviewed, along with quick kernels of advice like a “New Girl Action Plan,” ways to “Take Care of Yourself”, and even “Comeback Lines” for dealing with sexual harassment and other difficult situations.

100 she works HIS way Devotionals for the Working Woman

healthAuthor: Michelle Myers
Binding: Paperback
  • Michelle Myers
  • Erica Zoller
  • Leyton McKinney
  • Ashley McKinney

Studio: Myers Cross Training
Label: Myers Cross Training
Publisher: Myers Cross Training
Manufacturer: Myers Cross Training

Buy Now
Editorial Review: If you’re a woman juggling the priorities of faith, family, and work, we see you. We get you. And most of all, we are FOR YOU! Here’s the truth: Merely balancing your life will never work. You were divinely designed to put God first so He can order everything else (Matthew 6:33). she works His way exists to gather women just like you -- women who are committed to Christ, family, and that order. It’s our joy and honor to serve Kingdom-driven women through our annual conference, membership community, APP, and business tools. Rather than simply teaching business strategies and sprinkling in Scripture to support it, the majority of she works His way derives directly from God’s Word. Why? Because the Bible is the only book that truly transforms. If you’ve been longing for any kind of life transformation, God’s Word is the best place to find it.This book is a collection of 100 of our favorite devotionals that first appeared in the she works His way APP. Each one was written by a woman in the trenches of faith, family, and work with you from a heart’s desire to equip you as a Christ-follower, wife, mom, friend, leader, and professional. We are grateful to serve Jesus alongside women like you.


follow InnerSelf on


 Get The Latest By Email


follow InnerSelf on


 Get The Latest By Email