How Language Has Become A Tool For Social Exclusion

performance

How Language Has Become A Tool For Social Exclusion
Zurijeta/Shutterstock

Within a week of the Salzburg Global Seminar’s Statement for a Multilingual World launching in February 2018, the document – which calls for policies and practices that support multilingualism – had received 1.5m social media impressions.

The statement opens with some striking facts, including that “all 193 UN member states and most people are multilingual”. It also points out that 7,097 languages are currently spoken across the world but 2,464 of these are endangered. Just 23 languages dominate among these 7,097, and are spoken by over half of the world’s population.

As these statistics show, the soundtrack of our lives and the visual landscapes of our cities are multilingual. Languages, in their plurality, enrich our experience of the world and our creative potential. Multilingualism opens up new ways of being and of doing, it connects us with others and provides a window into the diversity of our societies. And yet, despite the more positive statistics above, we are currently witnessing a deep divide.

On the one hand, multilingualism is associated with mobility, productivity and knowledge creation (see, for instance, the EU’s objective for all citizens to speak two languages in addition to their first one). On the other, monolingualism (speaking only one language) is still perceived as both the norm and the ideal for an allegedly well-functioning society. Linguistic diversity is seen as both suspicious and costly.

Linguistic penalties

This is particularly visible in relation to the most vulnerable groups seeking a new home: refugees and asylum seekers. Newcomers are often required to prove they can read, write and speak the national language/s to be given the right to remain. Fluency, however, goes beyond technical ability in the majority languages. In the 1980s, researchers showed that language is more than just a code by which we communicate, it is related to social and political knowledge, and access to power structures.

Standing out from the crowd. (how language has become a tool for social exclusion)Standing out from the crowd. Nat.photo/Shutterstock

Language skills are critically important for engagement with a host society and lacking those skills can be an insurmountable barrier for accessing opportunities in education, work, and other areas of social life. Success in finding one’s place in a new social context, however, requires more than instrumental use of language.

Research has shown that refugees pay a “linguistic penalty” when transitioning to a new socioeconomic environment. That penalty refers to the consequences of being categorised as “different” or not “one of us” on the basis of language performance that does not follow established societal norms.

Speakers who inadvertently break societal rules of expected behaviour are assessed as “not having enough language”, which becomes a proxy for an inability to “fit in”. That inability, in turn, is interpreted as a moral deficiency: lack of fluency becomes a sign of insufficient desire to become “one of us” and marks the migrant as both a “failed” and a “bad” citizen.

Language, held up as a sign of belonging, becomes a gatekeeper for inclusion/exclusion, regulating access to citizenship and education, health and legal protection. The responsibility for success or failure falls firmly on the shoulders of the “other” – the migrant, the minority member, the one who “does not fit in”. This process is clearly visible in citizenship and language tests. The tests blur language assessment with reproducing and assessing abstract values about the home society. They take a narrow approach to cultural diversity and represent one hegemonic set of “ways of doing things around here”.

Deficit approach

The myth of one nation, one (national) language, one (national) culture – which was at the heart of the ideal of the nation state in the 19th and 20th centuries – perpetuates the master narrative of national homogeneity. The consistent and robust evidence that “native speakers” (a political term in its own right) fail citizenship tests and that the evaluation process is deeply political has not yet produced an alternative narrative.

By projecting a deficit approach onto refugees and asylum seekers, their contribution to society is dismissed and both their presence and the linguistic diversity attached to it are perceived as problems or costs. This mechanism of exclusion relies on a hierarchy in which not all languages are equal or desirable.

“Their” language(s) are low on the pecking order that the majority perceive as needed or wanted. Monolingual models insist on a “subtractive” principle in which one dominant language replaces another less “desirable” one, rather than recognising and valuing how multilingualism, by adding the ability to communicate in more than one language, can benefit everyone in our increasingly connected world.

These attitudes silence the contributions that new multilingual citizens make to economic growth, social cohesion or artistic production. A different approach is urgently needed, one that moves away from multilingualism as deficit and towards a recognition of linguistic and cultural diversity as a creative engine of civic participation and social well-being.

About the AuthorsThe Conversation

Loredana Polezzi, Professor in Translation Studies, Cardiff University; Jo Angouri, Professor of Applied Linguistics, University of Warwick, and Rita Wilson, Professor in Translation Studies, Monash University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Related Books

Cliques, Phonies & Other Baloney (Laugh & Learn®)

performanceAuthor: Trevor Romain
Binding: Kindle Edition
Format: Kindle eBook
Creator(s):
  • Steve Mark

Studio: Free Spirit Publishing
Label: Free Spirit Publishing
Publisher: Free Spirit Publishing
Manufacturer: Free Spirit Publishing

Buy Now
Editorial Review:
Revised classic provides a humorous take on cliques, exclusion, and real friends—updated to include online clique-tivity.​

Clique: It’s a word that’s spelled funny and sounds funny, and (like a vampire) can be a pain in the neck. True friends don’t make you feel left out, but for many kids, navigating social groups is tricky (because it’s cliquey), and they end up feeling excluded. This book uses humor, fun cartoons, and kid-friendly language to explain what cliques are, why being phony is baloney, why true friends don’t exclude others online or in real life, what’s more important than popularity—and how to navigate it all. The updated edition addresses online socializing and social media.

The Free Spirit Laugh & Learn® Series
Realistic topics, practical advice, silly jokes, fun illustrations, and a kid-centric point of view all add up to one of the most popular series young people turn to for help with school, families, siblings, and more. Kids ages 8–13 can tote these pocket-size guides anywhere and learn to slash stress, give cliques and rude people the boot, get organized, behave becomingly, and, in general, hugely boost their coping skills.




Cliques, Phonies, & Other Baloney (Laugh & Learn)

performanceAuthor: Trevor Romain
Binding: Paperback
Features:
  • Free Spirit Publishing

Brand: Free Spirit Publishing
Studio: Free Spirit Publishing
Label: Free Spirit Publishing
Publisher: Free Spirit Publishing
Manufacturer: Free Spirit Publishing

Buy Now
Editorial Review:
Cliques can make you sick. If you’re on the outside, you’re treated like dirt. And if you’re on the inside, you have to follow the rules. Who needs more rules at school?

Written for every kid who has ever felt excluded or trapped by a clique, this book blends humor with practical advice as it tackles a serious subject. Trevor Romain starts by explaining what cliques are and why they exist: because everyone wants to have friends. He reveals why some cliques are so annoying—and often full of phonies. And he shares the secret to being popular: just be yourself!

Trevor knows how to get through to kids. As readers smile at his cartoons and laugh at his jokes, they’ll also be learning skills they need to make and keep friends—real friends, not people who pretend to be cool. They’ll discover that some supposedly “popular” kids are lonely and miserable inside. And they’ll pick up important self-esteem tips that will help them feel good about themselves (because there’s no need to let a bad clique spoil a perfectly good day).

Part of the Bully Free Kids™ line




I'm Not Invited (Claire's Bullying Series)

performanceAuthor: Claire Burbank
Binding: Paperback
Creator(s):
  • Claire Burbank

Studio: Independently published
Label: Independently published
Publisher: Independently published
Manufacturer: Independently published

Buy Now
Editorial Review: Amelia Maskin had never experienced drama in school before...until sixth grade. Amelia and her two best friends, Ellie and Reyna, had been best friends since kindergarten. They were super excited to finally be going into sixth grade, to be older kids. They weren't expecting it, but some new kids were coming into their grade to learn alongside them. One of the new kids, Baylee, became one of their best friends. One day, Baylee, Ellie, and Reyna started telling secrets to each other, excluding Amelia from their conversations. Amelia didn't know what she did wrong, so she asked the three what they were talking about and why they weren't including her. After lots of interrogation occurred, she finally figured out what their secret was. Baylee was throwing a birthday party and not inviting Amelia. She was very upset, and didn't know what to do. And to make things worse, Baylee said to Amelia that she didn't want to be friends with her anymore. This made Amelia even more confused, and Ellie and Reyna told her some more bad news. "What could get worse?" Amelia thought. That's when Baylee dropped the bomb. She told Ellie and Reyna that they had to choose between her and Amelia! Read to find out what happens next! Themes of this book: www.claireburbank.com, Bullying, Values for kids, bullying books for kids, bullying books for children, values for kids, values for children, life lessons, friendship, children books, bullying in school, books for kids, school bullies, grade school bullies, parenting books, parenting books about bullying, middle school bullies, bullying books for parents, trouble with friends, lessons for kids, problems with friends, cute kids’ books, cyber bullying, young kids books, metaphorical bullying, bullying topics told in the form of a children’s book, social media bullying, anti-bullying, parenting, good parenting, good parents, solving bullying, solving bullying problems at school, mean kids, rude kids, stopping mean kids, stopping mean kids at school, problem solving, mean kids at school, stopping bullying, stop bullying me, stop bullying my friend, stop bullying NH, stop bullying right now, stop bullying me right now, bullies can become friends, teasing, dealing with kids who tease, bullying prevention, prevent bullying, www.stopbullyingnh.com, www.stopbullyingnh.org, stopbullyingme.org




performance
enafarzh-CNzh-TWtlfrdehiiditjamsptrues

follow InnerSelf on

google-plus-iconfacebook-icontwitter-iconrss-icon

 Get The Latest By Email

{emailcloak=off}

follow InnerSelf on

google-plus-iconfacebook-icontwitter-iconrss-icon

 Get The Latest By Email

{emailcloak=off}