Why Raw Meat Pet Food May Not Be Good For Your Dog, Or Your Own Health


Is Talking To Yourself A Sign Of Mental Illness? Be careful what you feed your dog. Shutterstock / fetrinka

You might think raw meat pet food is good for your dog. But a new study, published today in Vet Record, has found it can have high levels of bacteria that may pose health risks for your pet.

The researchers also warn that such food could present a health risk to you, or someone else in your house if his or her immune system is compromised. That includes children, the elderly or anyone taking any immune system suppressant medication for a health condition.

This is not the first time raw pet meat has been found to be contaminated with bacterial pathogens.

The latest study looked at samples from 60 commercially available raw pet meat products in Europe. The Swedish researchers tested these samples in the laboratory for pathogens such as E. coli, Salmonella and Campylobacter, which can cause disease in both pets and people.

All 60 samples were found to be contaminated with Enterobacteriaceae bacteria (the family to which E. coli belongs).

The finding of E. coli on a meat product suggests faecal contamination, as the bacteria are found in the gastrointestinal tracts of animals. It is also an indicator of poor hygiene during processing of the meat.

The contamination levels were found to vary among manufacturers but more than half the samples – 31 (52%) – exceeded the maximum threshold set by European Union regulations.

Other bacteria found in some of the samples, such as Salmonella, Clostridium perfringens and Campylobacter, are considered potentially pathogenic, which means they can cause serious illness in both animals and humans.

Is Talking To Yourself A Sign Of Mental Illness? Would you eat that? The standards are different for meat for pets compared to meat for human consumption. Shutterstock / Dvorakova Veronika

What is pet meat?

In Australia, raw meat pet foods, or pet meat, is defined as “meat in a raw state that is intended as food for pets”. This differentiates it from human-grade meat.

Human-grade meat is tightly regulated. For example, it is often subject to bacterial contamination testing to ensure the product is safe for human consumption.

Essentially, human-grade meat products are swabbed for E. coli and Salmonella just as they leave the abattoir. These swabs indicate the cleanliness of the meat processing and if there has been any faecal contamination.

Pet meat isn’t legally required to undergo bacterial testing in Australia, so it is unknown if pet meat here is contaminated like the samples in this Swedish study.

There are laws on how pet meat is manufactured and handled. But these laws are mainly concerned with protecting human safety from contamination and exposure to the pet meat, rather than ensuring it’s safe and wholesome for pets.

Laws for pet meat in Australia differ between states, which has been identified as an issue. The regulation of pet food (including pet meat) in Australia might soon be changing.

The risk to humans

The danger of raw pet meat contaminated with potentially pathogenic bacteria isn’t restricted to dogs eating the food as part of their diet.

Handling raw pet meat in your kitchen can also present a very real risk. The liquids from the meat can easily contaminate kitchen surfaces. Your dog’s mouth can also harbour these bacteria and spread them to you via licks and kisses.

That’s why anyone whose immune system may be compromised should not be exposed to raw pet meat.

It’s also for this reason, as well as the risks to the dogs themselves, that the US Food and Drug Administration does not support feeding dogs raw food.

Dogs can eat raw meat

We know that dogs have evolved to be able to eat raw meat. Dogs have stomachs and intestinal tracts that are slightly different from ours, which allows them to eat food that humans can’t eat.

But dogs can still get sick from bacteria in their food. We also know that dogs with gastrointestinal illness shed bacteria species, like those mentioned in the Swedish study, in their faeces to a much greater extent than healthy dogs.

Dogs can also get gastro from pathogenic bacteria such as Salmonella just like us.

Stressful environments such as kennels and veterinary hospitals can dampen the immune system. Dogs on medications like steroids or chemotherapy will also have reduced immunity to bacteria, including those in their diet.

How to keep yourself safe

The authors of this new study offer some great practical tips on how to keep yourself safe when handling raw pet meat.

  1. keep raw pet meat frozen until use
  2. handle raw pet meat separately from all other human food, and either use dedicated pet meat utensils or wash equipment thoroughly after use
  3. avoid kisses and licks from dogs that have just eaten raw pet meat
  4. do not feed raw pet meat in households with immunocompromised people.

You can further reduce the risk by only feeding human-grade meat to your dog, rather than pet meat, as the bacterial load and presence of other contaminants should be minimal.

Dogs require balanced diets with vitamins and minerals in certain ratios to avoid sickness, so all homemade diets should only be fed under the guidance of a veterinarian.The Conversation

Is Talking To Yourself A Sign Of Mental Illness? Your dog needs a balanced diet. Bronwyn Orr, Author provided

About The Author

Bronwyn Orr, Veterinarian and PhD candidate, University of Sydney

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Related Books

The Natural Pet Food Cookbook: Healthful Recipes for Dogs and Cats

petsAuthor: Wendy Nan Rees
Binding: Hardcover
  • Troy Cummings

Studio: Howell Book House
Label: Howell Book House
Publisher: Howell Book House
Manufacturer: Howell Book House

Buy Now
Editorial Review:
You Want The Best For Your Pets

After the massive commercial pet food recall in 2007, you're probably concerned about why to feed your dog or cat. The Natural Pet Food Cookbook: Healthful Recipes For Dogs And Cats gives you great ways to supplement your pet's primary diet with nutritious meals that you prepare; that way, you're sure your dog or cat gets healthy variety. With nn emphasis on natural ingredients and lots of colorful, fun illustrations, this cookbook gives you:
* More than 50 vet-approved, pet-tested recipes, ranging from basic kibble to casseroles to stews
* Tips on cooking techniques, food selection, and more
* Info on storing and freezing your homemade pet foods
* Details about the nutritional requirements of dogs and cats
* Warnings about potentially harmful foods

Raw and Natural Nutrition for Dogs, Revised Edition: The Definitive Guide to Homemade Meals

petsAuthor: Lew Olson
Binding: Paperback
  • Random House-Raw & Natural Nutrition For Dogs
  • The definitive guide to feeding your dog a balanced and nutritious raw and home-cooked diet, from the founder of a natural pets product company with over 30 years of experience working with dogs
  • This book contains charts with recipes, instructions on keeping diets simple and balanced, guidelines on preparation, suggestions for finding ingredients, and how much to feed a dog by body weight
  • Author: Lew Olson
  • Softcover; 276 pages

Brand: Random House
  • Christie Keith

Studio: North Atlantic Books
Label: North Atlantic Books
Publisher: North Atlantic Books
Manufacturer: North Atlantic Books

Buy Now
Editorial Review: The definitive guide to feeding your dog a balanced and nutritious raw and home-cooked diet, from the founder of a natural pets product company with over thirty years of experience working with dogs.

Many people want to prepare their dog's meals at home, but feel it is too complex. Raw and Natural Nutrition for Dogs provides a road map to the essentials of canine nutrition, written in easy-to-understand language.

Pet owners seeking to give their dogs a better coat, better skin, and healthier teeth and gums, as well as longer lives and more stable temperaments, will benefit not only from the background data in this book, but also the step-by-step instructions and recipes for preparing these diets. The book includes charts with the recipes, instructions on keeping diets simple and balanced, guidelines on preparation, suggestions for finding ingredients, and how much to feed a dog by body weight. There are recipes for healthy adult dogs, as well as guidelines for puppies, senior dogs, and dogs with health conditions including pancreatitis, renal problems, gastric issues, allergies, heart disease, liver disease, and cancer.

Tracing the history of feeding dogs, the author shows when commercial dog food rose and took hold of the market. She discusses canine nutritional needs and provides research on how home-prepared foods can meet pets' needs better than commercial, processed dog food. Written with thorough information for the seasoned raw feeder, this guide can also be easily followed by any newcomer to home-feeding.

This revised edition includes new information on special care and feeding of pregnant, newborn, performance, and toy breed dogs as well as senior dog considerations and the safety of the raw food diet for dogs.

Homemade Dog Food Natural Cook Recipes for your Pet with Love: Improve your Dog's Health with Easy and Delicious Recipes

petsAuthor: Jack Henry
Binding: Kindle Edition
Format: Kindle eBook

Buy Now
Are you sceptical for all these pre-made dog foods' ingredients and their safety?
Do you want to learn about the 4 Myths Making Your Own Dog Food?
Which foods not give to your dog and why?
And How to prepare Easily Fast, Delicious and Healthy Meals for your Pet, All In One Guide, that will Save you Money?
Your Step - by - Step Guide

In my short book, you will learn all you need to know about your dog's nutrition and how to prepare your own dog food.

You will learn, the quality of dog's food and it's safety.

How to replace foods for better quality.

Dog's diet evaluation.

Health problems like Kidney or Liver Failure and Cancer, Behavioral Problems Such as Short Attention Span, Arthritis and Joint Pain, Weight Loss and Much More your can Predict and Avoid by following these Delicious Home Made Recipes that your Dog will love, all included into this book!

Are you ready to start making your own dog's home made food for it's healthier way of life?

Press the "BUY NOW" button and get started right away!

Tags: Homemade Dog Food, Home Made, Cook, Cooking, Pet, Pets, Recipes, Dog Recipes, Cookbook, Cook Book, Natural, Dogs Food, Health, Pet Health, Dog Health, Dogs Health, Ingredients, Natural Ingredients, Food, Feed, Fresh, Fresh Ingredients, Nutrition, Dog Nutrition, Dogs Nutrition, Healthy Dog, Lifespan, Food Quality, Dog Feeding, Myth, Myths, Food Myths, Meal, Meals, Dog Meal, Dog Meals


follow InnerSelf on


 Get The Latest By Email


follow InnerSelf on


 Get The Latest By Email


Support A Good Job!