With suspicion surrounding staples such as eggs and the humble potato, along with the reconsideration of fats as not so bad, and the belated demonisation of the same sugars which were once marketed as beneficial – it’s no wonder consumers are becoming apprehensive about following advice on what they should, or should not put on their plates.
One of the more recently established buzzwords within food and nutrition has been probiotics – and the idea that you can help to “rebalance” your gut bacteria by adding a bit of good bacteria every day through the use of cultured consumer products. This has led to many people embracing a more “cultured” lifestyle by making sure that they have their daily dose of probiotic yogurt drink or supplement. But now, new research questions whether shop bought probiotics actually make any difference to our gut health at all.
The review of previous research on the topic, conducted by researchers at the University of Copenhagen, found no evidence that probiotics improve the balance of gut bacteria in healthy adults. While further clinical research is required to dig deeper into these findings, the results certainly contribute to the broader lingering concern that products marketed as healthy may not be so good for your health (or your pocket) after all.
The feeling that many of us may have been duped into buying “all singing, all dancing” probiotic brands comes at a time when people are increasingly migrating away from the supermarket to instead embrace homemade produce – including the use of home brewed fermented foods for hopes of a healthier gut.
These fermented foods are items which have gone through a process of “lactofermentation”. This is where natural bacteria feed on the sugar and starch in the food creating lactic acid. This process preserves the food, and creates various strains of probiotics, along with beneficial enzymes, b-vitamins and Omega-3 fatty acids.
When it comes to fermenting food there are already a whole host of DIY options out there, such as pickles, miso, sauerkraut and kimchi. It might seem backwards to ditch the probiotic drinks available at the local supermarket, in favour of sealing up and storing vegetables in jars of brine around our kitchens – to mature that perfect sauerkraut – but the general principle that underpins such behaviour cannot be ignored.
The interest in “home brewing” comes as part of a change in consumption with people moving away from pre-packed “marketised science”, to instead seek out their own personal, experiential and enlightened paths to wellness.
Get The Latest From InnerSelf
Whether home brew options actually provide any benefit to gut health, beyond what is sold in the supermarket, is fairly unknown, but for many people they at least constitute a more “natural” culinary process that allows understanding and working intimately with one’s own body.
This change in our relationship with food can be explained by the rise of “diets of enlightenment”. In his book The Omnivorous Mind: Our Evolving Relationship With Food, author John S. Allen looks at how certain consumers are moving away from weight-loss and preoccupations with thinness. They are instead focusing more on holism, emotion, personal opinion and experience when it comes to their food.
Over the past couple of years, there has been an ongoing explosion of “alternative” food trends, dietary movements and gastronomic experimentalism that fit Allen’s ideas of enlightened eating. Whether it’s clean eating, freeganism, advocacy for raw foods, wild food foraging, the rise of the venerable “hegan” (that’s a male vegan to you and me), or fans of the organic or seasonal option, it’s a new way of thinking about food.
A significant number of people now seem to be choosing their approaches to eating for reasons less to do with nutrition and more to do with wellness, sustainability and the search for identity. So goes the saying, you are what you eat.
This has coincided with a rise in food bloggers, YouTubers and Instagrammers, all raving about their latest culinary masterpiece while subscribing to a particular philosophy when it comes to their food related lifestyle. Matcha soy latte anyone?
With consumers becoming more sceptical and disinterested with the “ideology of nutritionism” – which drives much of the food marketing we see at our supermarkets – personal paths to enlightenment are leading shoppers to shun the “marketised science” of the food industry, in favour of homemade, experiential, and locally sourced options.
This means big food corporations may need to start thinking more creatively and holistically about their health offerings to remain credible in the age of the food revolution. Continuing to plonk new specially engineered and marketed yogurt brands in supermarket chillers may no longer be enough to appease the enlightened, “experience thirsty” and “identity seeking” consumer.
The new wave of enlightened eaters enjoy the broader experience of culturing these things for themselves rather than simply buying them in a packet. While most shoppers won’t be popping down to the local markets to stock up on the raw ingredients to ferment their own foods any time soon, it is possible that home brew kits could hit the supermarket shelves at some point in the future – as the big brands try to get in on the culturing action.
But for now, we are seeing people simply take control of their own health, without having to depend on the uneasy combination of marketing and science that usually accompanies what they buy. Instead they are getting along fine with just a jar, some brine, and some chopped up vegetables.
About The Author
James Cronin, Lecturer in Marketing and Consumer Behaviour, Lancaster University