Can Trying To Meet Specific Exercise Goals Put Us Off Being Active Altogether?


Can Trying To Meet Specific Exercise Goals Put Us Off Being Active Altogether?
Exercise practitioners and personal trainers are taught to help us set goals.

Encouraging people to meet specific fitness goals when they are new to exercising can be ineffective. In fact, it may even make it harder to become active, according to an editorial published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine.

Does this sound familiar?

Every time I join a gym, I get pressured into writing down a goal, when I just want to exercise a few times a week. And I often feel like a failure if I’m no closer to my goal after a few months, so I stop going altogether.

This is the experience a friend shared with me after I told her about our latest paper. And it makes sense. Exercise practitioners and personal trainers are taught to help us set goals, and often we try setting our own exercise goals - such as New Years’ resolutions.

But what if the way we set these goals isn’t actually that helpful, or worse, makes it harder for us to become more active?

Why do we set specific goals?

Specific, challenging goals are widely accepted and recommended as being most effective for increasing performance, based on over 50 years of research. This is why a personal trainer may encourage us to set a goal like losing 5kg over the next 12 weeks by committing to a program including at least three visits to the gym per week.

Indeed, peak exercise bodies, such as the American College of Sports Medicine, advise practitioners that in order to be effective, goals need to follow the SMART principle. This means they should be Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic, and Time-bound.

Even the World Health Organisation guidelines include specific targets for physical activity, such as participating in at least 150 minutes of moderate intensity physical activity throughout the week.

However, important aspects of the theory around goal setting seem to have been oversimplified, overlooked, or misunderstood. Specific goals are often used in a one-size-fits-all manner, where it is assumed they are equally effective for people of different skill levels.

If we’re already skilled, or in this case physically active, then specific goals are great for getting more out of ourselves. Alternatively, if the task isn’t complex - like simply trying to increase a daily step count - then specific goals can work well.

Yet increasing and maintaining physical activity long term is a complex process, so this issue is very relevant for our attempts to exercise and get fit. The theory also states that when we’re in the early stages of learning new, complex tasks, specific goals aren’t as effective as goals such as to do your best – and could even be harmful to our attempts. Just imagine being set a specific goal to cycle 100 metres the very first time you get on a bike.

get on a bike (can trying to meet specific exercise goals put us off being active altogether)Imagine being told to cycle 100 metres the first time you get on a bike. Photo by Blubel on Unsplash, CC BY

There is good evidence of this too. For example, a large review of studies looked at interventions which used goal setting to increase physical activity. It found specific goals were no more effective at increasing physical activity than vague goals such as to simply “be more active”.

See how active you can be

Problems with the current approach of setting goals include focusing on immediate or short-term outcomes (like losing 1kg this week), diverting attention away from strategy development (aiming to get through a 20 minute run rather than understanding how to pace yourself), and inhibiting learning (achieving less knowledge of how to exercise appropriately).

Specific goals may be off-putting if we believe they’re unrealistic, hence the Achievable and Realistic in SMART. So we might even think “I won’t be able to achieve 150 minutes of physical activity this week - why bother trying?”

Specific goals also introduce the possibility of failure, which is a negative feeling and can be extremely demotivating. For example, you could think:

I wanted to run for half an hour but only managed 15 minutes – I’m so bad at this!

In this way, specific goals can distract you from your achievements:

I ran for 15 minutes today even though I was busy – that’s not bad.

Instead of automatically relying on specific, challenging targets when we’re trying to become more active, we need to re-think how we set goals, and look at other options. According to the theory and based on promising results from initial studies, open goals like “see how active you can be” seem to be a great way to start.

After that, you could focus on beating what you achieved last time, and on incremental improvements rather than lofty goals planned in advance.

You can also focus on developing strategies for becoming more active, like trying out different times and days when you can make it to the gym, or different pieces of gym equipment. And you can focus on the process of learning how to be active, like learning how to pace yourself if you go for a run.

By simply changing how your goals are phrased, it might become easier to get active, and stay active for longer.The Conversation

About The Authors

Christian Swann, Associate Research Fellow, University of Wollongong and Simon Rosenbaum, Society For Mental Health Research Early Career Fellow, UNSW

Artikel ini terbit pertama kali di The Conversation. Baca artikel sumber.

Related Books

Eyegames: Easy and Fun Visual Exercises: An OT and Optometrist Offer Activities to Enhance Vision!

fitnessAuthor: Lois Hickman
Binding: Paperback
  • Used Book in Good Condition

Brand: Brand: Sensory World
Studio: Sensory World
Label: Sensory World
Publisher: Sensory World
Manufacturer: Sensory World

Buy Now
Editorial Review:

This book represents an introduction to the human senses for kids. It might be your child’s first “read about your own problems” guide. It explains what can go wrong when the brain inappropriately magnifies the messages sense organs send to it.

Making inappropriate responses to sensory input from various senses is commonly referred to as sensory processing disorder, or SPD. The child avoids, resists, or becomes emotionally upset about experiencing sensory awareness, to a level that significantly interferes with a child’s ability to perform the necessary major functions of daily living. This book is a therapy guide for any child with sensory issues

Exercises for the Brain and Memory : 70 Top Neurobic Exercises & FUN Puzzles to Increase Mental Fitness & Boost Your Brain Juice Today: (Special 2 In 1 Exclusive Edition)

fitnessAuthor: Jason Scotts
Binding: Paperback
  • For all our books; Cargo will be delivered in the required time. 100% Satisfaction is Guaranteed!

Studio: Speedy Publishing LLC
Label: Speedy Publishing LLC
Publisher: Speedy Publishing LLC
Manufacturer: Speedy Publishing LLC

Buy Now
Editorial Review: If you are interested in learning the best ways possible to improve mental health then you need a copy of "Exercises For The Brain & Memory : 70 Neurobic Exercises & Fun Puzzles To Increase Mental Fitness & Boost Your Brain Juice Today (Special 2 In 1 Edition)." This text is written in a fashion that is easy to understand and the author himself has used quite a number of the techniques outlined in the text to his own benefit. As more and more persons seek better ways to retain and improve their memory this text is well timed. It gives the reader the solutions that they need to get started on the path to having a fantastic memory. Just as the body needs physical exercises in order to function correctly, the brain needs to be exercised as well to prevent it from becoming sluggish. In addition, you've probably heard the saying that as you get older, you starting becoming more forgetful and your brain just doesn't function as well as it used to in your prime. Well, that eventuality can be slowed down in a fun way that most people enjoy which is figuring out or solving puzzles. ""Exercises For The Brain & Memory : 70 Neurobic Exercises & Fun Puzzles To Increase Mental Fitness & Boost Your Brain Juice Today (Special 2 In 1 Edition)" will help you improve your concentration and focus your mind. The mental exercises in this book will juice up your brain and not only are they exciting to do, but the mental stimulation can make you feel energized and ready to remember anything. If you are able, do one puzzle every other day or at least several times per week so that there's a consistency in doing these fun mental exercises. Before you know it, your mind will become more focused and your concentration will improve. You don't need to complete them in order; just flip through the pages and find one that you're in the mood to do on a particular day.

Social Skills Activities for Kids: 50 Fun Exercises for Making Friends, Talking and Listening, and Understanding Social Rules

fitnessAuthor: Natasha Daniels
Binding: Paperback
Studio: Rockridge Press
Label: Rockridge Press
Publisher: Rockridge Press
Manufacturer: Rockridge Press

Buy Now
Editorial Review:

Learn Everyday Social Skills and Have Fun, Too!

What are the Dos and Don’ts for making and keeping friends? How can you decode body language clues? What’s the best way to keep a conversation going? Just like learning multiplication tables, social skills don’t come naturally―every child has to learn them. Luckily, this book makes mastering social skills super fun with 50 awesome activities.

Social Skills Activities for Kids gives children the confidence to successfully navigate social situations at home, school, and the world in between. From keeping the conversation ball moving to learning to compromise to practicing good table manners, these engaging activities help kids develop and use their social skills super powers.

Inside Social Skills Activities for Kids, you’ll find:

  • Life Lessons―Kids learn how to handle everyday social situations like communicating with peers and adults, using and interpreting body language, reading social cues, and more.
  • 50 Interactive Activities―Games, fill-in-the-blank exercises, and reflective entries keep kids learning and engaged.
  • Real Scenarios―Includes up-to-date topics like bullying and using social media.

Get the courage to be your very best self with Social Skills Activities for Kids.


follow InnerSelf on


 Get The Latest By Email


follow InnerSelf on


 Get The Latest By Email