These Non-medical Talks Elicit Better End Of Life Plans


These Non-medical Talks Elicit Better End Of Life Plans

New research suggests better results when people with serious diseases discuss their end-of-life decisions with a non-clinical worker.

The findings suggest that patients with a serious illness are more at ease with decisions about their care when they discuss their care preferences with someone outside the medical context, say the researchers.

Patients with advanced cancer who spoke with a trained nonclinical worker about personal goals for care were more likely to talk with doctors about their preferences, report higher satisfaction with their care, and incur lower health costs in their final month of life, researchers from the Stanford University School of Medicine report.

Lead author Manali Patel, assistant professor of medicine, and her colleagues employed a lay health worker to conduct conversations with 213 patients about their personal desires for care and to encourage them to share this information with providers.

The intervention, which appears in JAMA Oncology, was based on prior research that Patel conducted when she was a fellow at Stanford’s Clinical Excellence Research Center, in which patients expressed a preference for having these discussions with nonclinical workers.

“A goals-of-care conversation is not about prognosis. It’s a holistic approach to understanding the patient’s wishes and how they want to experience their life,” Patel says. “You don’t need higher-level training to have that conversation. You just need a very supportive ear.”

Questions about end-of-life

Patel and her fellow researchers followed patients at the Veterans Affairs Palo Alto Health Care System for 15 months after they received a diagnosis of stage-3 or -4 cancer or with recurrent cancer. Half were randomly assigned to speak with a lay health worker about goals of care over a six-month period.

The lay health worker had participated in a training curriculum that Patel created that included an 80-hour online seminar, as well as four weeks of observational training with the hospital’s palliative care team. During several telephone and in-person conversations, the worker led patients through a structured program that addressed questions, such as:

  • “What is your understanding of your cancer?”
  • “What is important to you?”
  • “Have you thought about a time when you could be sicker?”
  • “How would you want to spend your time in that situation?”

Together, they also established care preferences, identified a surrogate decision-maker, and filed an advance directive.

“We trained the worker to address these questions over multiple time periods and to revisit the conversation when unexpected events occurred, such as an emergency department visit or bad scan results,” Patel says.

“How a patient feels and what they express as their desires today may be different from how they may feel a week from now, if they had a really horrible side effect from the chemotherapy that they’re receiving and they’re finding themselves in the hospital for two weeks rather than spending the time with their family.”

Higher satisfaction

Patients in the study who participated in conversations with the lay health worker were more likely to have documentation of end-of-life care preferences in their electronic health records within six months of those conversations starting (92 percent compared with 18 percent in the control group). Researchers used this documentation to gauge whether patients had discussed the topic with their doctors.

Patients in the intervention group also rated their oncology care higher, giving it an average satisfaction score of 9.16 out of 10, compared with the average of 7.83 from the control group. They also posted higher satisfactions scores when queried about their care-related decision-making.

“This indicates that patients in the intervention were having a better experience with their providers despite having been prompted and activated to discuss really difficult topics,” Patel says. “This is consistent with what other studies have shown indicating that patients value honest and open communication regarding their prognosis.”

Lower costs of care

The researchers also monitored health-care costs and use among patients in the two groups.

They found few significant differences over 15 months; however, for patients who died during the study, the final 30 days diverged markedly. Those who discussed goals of care with the lay health worker were six times less likely to visit the emergency department or be hospitalized than members of the control group, and twice as likely to use hospice services. Their median health care cost within 30 days of death was $1,048, compared with $23,482 for the control group.

Overall, patients who participated in conversations with the lay health worker used hospice at higher rates than the control group—a finding that tracks with other research, Patel says.

“Consistently, patients who understand that they have an incurable cancer are more likely to choose less aggressive care, and we see that same result here,” she says. “Communication and listening to patients seem to be the common theme because when providers listen to patients and they’re receiving care that’s concordant with their goals, they seem to have better outcomes, especially at the end of life.”

Support for the work came from the California Health Care Foundation, Veterans Affairs Office of Healthcare Transformation Specialty Care, and the National Institutes of Health, as well as Stanford’s departments of Medicine and of Health Research & Policy.

Source: Stanford University

Related Books:

Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End

financeAuthor: Atul Gawande
Binding: Paperback
Studio: Picador
Label: Picador
Publisher: Picador
Manufacturer: Picador

Buy Now
Editorial Review:

Named a Best Book of the Year by The Washington Post, The New York Times Book Review, NPR, and Chicago Tribune, now in paperback with a new reading group guide

Medicine has triumphed in modern times, transforming the dangers of childbirth, injury, and disease from harrowing to manageable. But when it comes to the inescapable realities of aging and death, what medicine can do often runs counter to what it should.

Through eye-opening research and gripping stories of his own patients and family, Gawande reveals the suffering this dynamic has produced. Nursing homes, devoted above all to safety, battle with residents over the food they are allowed to eat and the choices they are allowed to make. Doctors, uncomfortable discussing patients' anxieties about death, fall back on false hopes and treatments that are actually shortening lives instead of improving them.

In his bestselling books, Atul Gawande, a practicing surgeon, has fearlessly revealed the struggles of his profession. Now he examines its ultimate limitations and failures-in his own practices as well as others'-as life draws to a close. Riveting, honest, and humane, Being Mortal shows how the ultimate goal is not a good death but a good life-all the way to the very end.

Dying Well: Peace and Possibilities at the End of Life

financeAuthor: Ira Byock MD
Binding: Paperback
  • For all our books; Cargo will be delivered in the required time. 100% Satisfaction is Guaranteed!

Studio: Riverhead Books
Label: Riverhead Books
Publisher: Riverhead Books
Manufacturer: Riverhead Books

Buy Now
Editorial Review: From Ira Byock, prominent palliative care physician and expert in end of life decisions, a lesson in Dying Well.

Nobody should have to die in pain. Nobody should have to die alone.

This is Ira Byock's dream, and he is dedicating his life to making it come true. Dying Well brings us to the homes and bedsides of families with whom Dr. Byock has worked, telling stories of love and reconciliation in the face of tragedy, pain, medical drama, and conflict. Through the true stories of patients, he shows us that a lot of important emotional work can be accomplished in the final months, weeks, and even days of life. It is a companion for families, showing them how to deal with doctors, how to talk to loved ones—and how to make the end of life as meaningful and enriching as the beginning.

Ira Byock is also the author of The Best Care Possible: A Physician's Quest to Transform Care Through the End of Life.

Palliative Care Nursing: Quality Care to the End of Life, Fifth Edition - New Chapter Included - Instructor Resources

financeBinding: Hardcover
  • Marianne Matzo PhD APRN-CNP FPCN FAAN
  • Deborah Witt Sherman PhD APRN ANP-BC ACHPN FAAN

Studio: Springer Publishing Company
Label: Springer Publishing Company
Publisher: Springer Publishing Company
Manufacturer: Springer Publishing Company

Buy Now
Editorial Review: The aging population has only grown since the first edition of this comprehensive and seminal publication released nearly 20 years ago. Based on the need to humanize rather than medicalize the illness experience for patients, Palliative Care Nursing: Quality Care to the End of Life, Fifth Edition, delves into palliative care beyond the specific diseases affecting the patient. ICU nursing and ICU style help is impersonal and outdated. Instead, this textbook focuses on the wholesome caregiving to benefit the patient and their support network.

Palliative patients struggle with debilitating and painful conditions, and because their condition is chronic, they grapple with the fact that life as they knew it has ended. Families and friends also suffer. They don't know how to help and therefore become secondary victims of the disease. Traditionally, ICU units and have focused on just treatment, and patients, family, and friends suffered. Today, modern medical advances have expanded to include empathy, and have learned how to harness the power of an entire team to help the patient and their support network strengthen their resilience, cure what can be cured, and maintain meaning and purpose in life.

Palliative Care Nursing, Fifth Edition delivers advanced empirical, aesthetic, ethical and personal knowledge. This new edition brings an increased focus on outcomes, benchmarking progress, and goals of care. It expounds upon the importance of the cross-disciplinary collaboration introduced in the previous edition. Every chapter in Sections I, II, and III includes content written by a non-nursing member of the interprofessional team. Based on best-evidence and clinical practice guidelines, this text presents comprehensive, targeted interventions responsive to the needs of palliative and hospice patients and family. Each chapter contains compassionate, timely, appropriate, and cost-effective care for diverse populations across the illness trajectory.

The updated fifth edition includes:
  • An expanded chapter on palliative care which thoroughly explains up-to-date scope and standards, information on Basic and Advanced HPNA certification, self-reflection and self-care for nurses
  • A new chapter on Interprofessional Collaboration
  • Valuable instructor resources including practice problems, PowerPoints, practice tests and test banks

Key features of this palliative care and ICU book include:
  • The expanded new edition offers current, comprehensive, one-stop source of highly-relevant clinical information on palliative medicine
  • Life-span approach: age-appropriate nursing considerations (e.g. geriatric, pediatric and family)
  • Includes disease-specific and symptom-specific nursing management chapters
  • Promotes a holistic and interdisciplinary approach to palliative care
  • Offers important legal, ethical and cultural considerations related to death and dying
  • Case Studies with Case Study Conclusion in each clinical chapter

“This 5th edition is an important achievement; it is a symbol of commitment to the field of palliative nursing, where we have been and where we are going.”
- Betty Rolling Ferrell, PhD, MA, FAAN, FPCN, CHPN


follow InnerSelf on


 Get The Latest By Email


follow InnerSelf on


 Get The Latest By Email