How Hot-deskers Feel Like Homeless Workers


How Hot-deskers Feel Like Homeless Workers

If you work in an open-plan, hot-desking environment, you have probably at some point found yourself trudging through the office, clutching your belongings, in search of a free desk. This feeling of homelessness is an increasing issue in society more broadly – and in the workplace, employees’ well-being is traded in for the company’s bottom line.

These were some of my conclusions after spending three years studying an organisation that moved to a hot-desk environment. Like many companies, it had switched to hot-desking to reduce property costs and enable precious office space to be used flexibly.

In the language of facilities management, an office building can be “crunched” by increasing the staff to desks ratio, and it can be “restacked” as teams and departments are moved around like boxes. But in this bid for cost-cutting, a number of employees are made to feel under-appreciated at best and unwanted at worst.

As an ethnographer, I experienced this first hand by embedding myself within the company. It was when I was traipsing around, carrying my work bag, handbag, umbrella, coat and lunch one day that I suddenly realised: I must look like a bag lady; this is not how high status people have to act.

Proponents of hot-desking say it creates a more dynamic working environment. They espouse that it enhances networking within an organisation, due to all the people you unexpectedly encounter as you move around. Yet the reality seems to be quite different.

Settlers and strangers

Hot-desking tends to affect different employees in different ways. There is often a subtle division between those who can “settle” and reliably occupy the same desk every day, and those who cannot.

Settlers arrive first, choose their preferred desk, and by repeating their choice over time, establish this desk as “their” space. Settlers can secure the best desk space (often near the windows), can furnish their desks with all the materials and equipment needed for work, and can sit near their closest colleagues. These routines are advantageous. Contrary to popular belief, these kinds of habits enable creativity because they enable us to put mundane matters (like finding a seat near to people we know) into the background and direct our attention onto problem-solving and innovation.

Employees who for various reasons (such as childcare responsibilities or part-time status) arrive later in the day don’t have a similar choice of desk space. Because some desks have already been taken, the staff to desks ratio is effectively increased. If you find yourself in this situation, your search for a space, encumbered by your possessions, proclaims your uncertain status. Then, once you have found a free desk, you have to unpack all your work things and set yourself up before you can begin productive work (and then repack it all when you leave) – spending more time every day on low-level subsistence activity.

You will also be sitting regularly alongside relative strangers. It’s not acceptable to introduce yourself, because that would interrupt them. Instead, the normal manner is what sociologist Erving Goffman calls “civil inattention”. This is the practice of signalling to others nearby that you are not available for communication with them, despite your close proximity – it’s the kind of manner most people adopt on a crowded commuter train.

In the workplace, this can feel incredibly isolating. As one of my informants remarked: “Every day could be your first day at work.” It does not indicate readiness for networking and collaboration.

Slippery spaces

This distinction between settlers and wandering hot-deskers has striking parallels with how vagrants move around a city, carefully giving priority to the settled “host” population. The host population can occupy the prime space in the city, which offers comfort and pleasure, and indicates their high status (for instance, shopping, business and entertainment). Vagrants must defer to the hosts, carefully observing when and how they might be permitted to enter the city’s prime spaces, resigned to the fact that they will spend most of their time at the margins.

The analogy shouldn’t be pushed too far: the problems experienced by hot-deskers are, of course, not anything like the awful hardship and marginalisation that homeless people have to cope with. But the analogy helps to show the material and symbolic disadvantages that can come with a lack of ownership of space.

It also points to a wider situation where our ownership and occupation of space is becoming more temporary and tenuous. Many contemporary spaces are designed to be slippery – shopping malls have few benches and are security-patrolled to deter loitering; transport hubs have uncomfortable slanted seats that hurry us along. There are even “smart” park benches that have been designed to tip the sitter off after the time permitted for relaxation has elapsed.

The plight of the hot-desker therefore forms part of a wider social issue where space is designed in a way that allows it to be used intensively by many different people. But in so doing, it may deprive of us of the ability to put down roots with the places and people we encounter every day.The Conversation

About The Author

Alison Hirst, Director of Postgraduate Research, Anglia Ruskin University

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Related Books

The Disrupted Workplace: Time and the Moral Order of Flexible Capitalism

careerAuthor: Benjamin H. Snyder
Binding: Paperback
Studio: Oxford University Press
Label: Oxford University Press
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Manufacturer: Oxford University Press

Buy Now
Editorial Review: The twenty-first century workplace compels Americans to be more flexible, often at a cost to their personal well-being. In The Disrupted Workplace, Benjamin Snyder examines how three groups of American workers construct moral order in a capitalist system that demands flexibility. Snyder argues that new scheduling techniques, employment strategies, and technologies disrupt the flow and trajectory of working life, transforming how workers experience time. Work can feel both liberating and terrorizing, engrossing in the short term but unsustainable in the long term. Through a vivid portrait of workers' struggles to adapt their lives to constant disruption, The Disrupted Workplace mounts a compelling critique of the price of the flexible economy.

Managing in a Flexible Workplace

careerAuthor: Barney Olmsted
Binding: Hardcover
  • Used Book in Good Condition

Brand: Brand: AMACOM
Studio: AMACOM
Publisher: AMACOM
Manufacturer: AMACOM

Buy Now
Editorial Review: The "flexible" workplace is now a daily reality. But how is a busy manager supposed to supervise telecommuters, schedule flextime employees, communicate with all his or her staff, and still meet organizational demands?

This nitty-gritty guide was written specifically for managers and supervisors in today's flexible workplace who must take advantage of flexibility -- not let it become yet another managerial burden. This concise toolkit explains:

** the benefits and challenges of nine typical flex options (including flextime, flexplace, compressed work week, regular part time, and job sharing)
** how to use flexibility as a tool for greater efficiency
** the many benefits of workplace flexibility, such as: allocating people and resources more effectively, building commitment and increasing productivity by cooperating with employees' needs, finding alternatives to layoffs, reducing labor costs, minimizing absenteeism, attracting quality people who can't (or won't) work in a traditional structure.

Workflex: The Essential Guide to Effective and Flexible Workplaces

careerAuthor: Families and Work Institute
Binding: Kindle Edition
Format: Kindle eBook
Studio: Society For Human Resource Management
Label: Society For Human Resource Management
Publisher: Society For Human Resource Management
Manufacturer: Society For Human Resource Management

Buy Now
Editorial Review:

For today’s fast-paced and diverse workforce, workplace flexibility is a crucial element for success on and off the job. Employers who recognize this new and profound reality are a step ahead of the competition in recruiting and retaining high performing talent. A forward-looking and important benchmark resource for organizations, business leaders, and employees, this account provides comprehensive and in-depth information on how to implement a flexible workplace. It is filled with examples, how-to information, advice from experts, and tools to help employers and HR professionals set up and maintain flexible work arrangements that help meet their needs and the needs of their employees.


follow InnerSelf on


 Get The Latest By Email


follow InnerSelf on


 Get The Latest By Email