The Flat-Tax Fraud

Herman Cain’s bizarre 9-9-9 plan would replace much of the current tax code with a 9 percent individual income tax and a 9 percent sales tax. He calls it a “flat tax.”

Next week Rick Perry is set to announce his own version of a flat tax. Former House majority leader Dick Armey – now chairman of Freedom Works, a major backer of the Tea Party funded by the Koch Brothers and other portly felines (I didn’t say “fat cats”) — predicts this will give Perry “a big boost.” Steve Forbes, one of America’s richest billionaires, who’s on the board of the Freedom Works foundation, is delighted. He’s been pushing the flat tax for years.

The flat tax is a fraud. It raises taxes on the poor and lowers them on the rich.

We don’t know exactly what Perry will propose, but the non-partisan Tax Policy Center estimates that Cain’s plan (the only one out there so far) would lower the after-tax incomes of poor households (incomes below $30,000) by 16 to 20 percent, while increasing the incomes of wealthier households (incomes above $200,000) by 5 to 22 percent, on average.

Under Cain’s plan, fully 95 percent of households with more than $1 million in income would get an average tax cut of $487,300. And capital gains (a major source of income for the very rich) would be tax free.

The details of flat-tax proposals vary, of course. But all of them end up benefitting the rich more than the poor for one simple reason: Today’s tax code is still at least moderately progressive. The rich usually pay a higher percent of their incomes in income taxes than do the poor. A flat tax would eliminate that slight progressivity.

Nowadays most low-income households pay no federal income tax at all – a fact that sends many regressives into spasms of indignation. They conveniently ignore the fact that poor households pay a much larger share of their incomes in payroll taxes, sales taxes, and property taxes (directly, if they own their homes; indirectly, if they rent) than do people with high incomes.

Flat-taxers pretend a flat tax is good public policy, for two reasons.

First, they say, it would simplify paying taxes. Baloney. Flat-tax proposals don’t eliminate popular deductions. (I’ll be surprised if Perry’s plan eliminates the popular mortgage-interest deduction, for example.) So most tax payers would still have to fill out lots of forms.

Second, they say a flat tax is fairer than the current system because, in Cain’s words, a flat tax “treats everyone the same.”

The truth is the current tax code treats everyone the same. It’s organized around tax brackets. Everyone whose income reaches the same bracket is treated the same as everyone else whose income reaches that bracket (apart from various deductions, exemptions, and credits, of course).

For example, no one pays any income taxes on the first $20,000 or so of their income (the exact amount depends on whether the person is married and eligible for tax credits like the Earned Income Tax Credit of the Family Tax Credit.)

People in higher brackets pay a higher rate only on the portion of their income that hits that bracket — not on their entire incomes.

So when Barack Obama calls for ending the Bush tax cut on incomes over $250,000, he’s only talking about the portion peoples’ incomes that exceed $250,000. He’s not proposing to tax their entire incomes at the higher rate that prevailed under Bill Clinton.

Republicans have tried to sow confusion about this. They want Americans to believe, for example, that if the Bush tax cut ended, small business owners with incomes of $251,000 a year would suddenly have to pay 39 percent of their entire incomes in taxes rather than 35 percent. Wrong. They’d only have to pay the 39 percent rate on $1,000 – the portion of their incomes over $250,000.

Get it? We already have a flat tax – flat within each bracket.

The real problem is the top brackets are set too low relative to where the money is. The top-most bracket starts at $375,000 a year. People with incomes higher than that pay 35 percent – again, only on that portion of their incomes exceeding $375,000.

This is absurd. It means a professional who’s making, say, $380,000 a year pays the same income-tax rate as a plutocrat pulling in $2 billion or $20 billion.

Our current flat tax at the top is treating the nation’s professional class exactly the same as it treats super-rich plutocrats. My doctor pays the same rate as Steve Forbes.

Actually, it’s worse than that because the plutocrats get most of their income in the form of capital gains, which are taxed at only 15 percent. That’s why America’s 400 richest people – who earned an average of $300 million last year, and who have more wealth than the bottom 150 million Americans put together – now pay at a 17 percent rate (according to the IRS).

The Republicans’ push for a flat tax masks what’s really going on.

Remember: The top 1 percent is now raking in over 20 percent of the nation’s total income and owns over 35 percent of the nation’s wealth. Under almost anyone’s view of fairness, these are grotesque portions. They’re especially large relative to what they were as recently as thirty years ago, when the top 1 percent raked in under 10 percent. And these huge portions at the top continue to increase.

Meanwhile, the top tax bracket is now 35 percent — the lowest it’s been in three decades. Between the end of World War II and 1980 it never fell below 70 percent. 

Simple fairness requires three things: More tax brackets at the top, higher rates in each bracket, and the treatment of all sources of income (capital gains included) exactly the same.

Not only fairness demands it, but also fiscal prudence. A truly progressive tax would bring in tens of billions of dollars a year from the people at the top who are in the best position to afford it.

Regressives are pushing the flat tax as a smokescreen. They’d rather not have anyone talk about the unfairness and fiscal absurdity of the current system.

Rather than merely oppose the flat tax, sensible people should push for a truly progressive tax – starting with a top rate of 70 percent on that portion of anyone’s income exceeding $5 million, from whatever source.


* This article was sourced from (Rights retained by author.)

About The Author

Robert Reich author of Wall Street Occupiers and the Democratic PartyRobert Reich is Chancellor's Professor of Public Policy at the University of California at Berkeley. He has served in three national administrations, most recently as secretary of labor under President Bill Clinton. He has written thirteen books, including The Work of Nations, Locked in the Cabinet, Supercapitalism, and his most recent book, Aftershock. His "Marketplace" commentaries can be found on and iTunes. He is also Common Cause's board chairman.

Recommended Book

Aftershock by Robert ReichAftershock: The Next Economy and America's Future (Vintage) by Robert B. Reich (Paperback - Apr 5, 2011) In Aftershock, Reich argues that Obama's stimulus package will not catalyze real recovery because it fails to address 40 years of increasing income inequality. The lessons are in the roots of and responses to the Great Depression, according to Reich, who compares the speculation frenzies of the 1920s–1930s with present-day ones, while showing how Keynesian forerunners like FDR's Federal Reserve Board chair, Marriner Eccles, diagnosed wealth disparity as the leading stress leading up to the Depression.

Red and Blue States Agree on Taxing Corporations More (and Lots of Other Stuff)

Red and Blue States Agree on Taxing Corporations (and Lots of Other Stuff)

by Miriam Axel-Lute. What if you asked Americans in largely "red" or Republican districts and largely "blue" or Democratic…
Continue reading
How to Shrink Income and Wealth Inequality

How to Shrink Income and Wealth Inequality

The pertinent question is not whether income and wealth inequality is good or bad. It is at what point do these inequalities…
Continue reading
Why Boston Has the Best Tasting Tap Water in the Country

Why Boston Has the Best Tasting Tap Water in the Country

The secret ingredient in Boston's prize winning tap water? Forest conservation. If you already love Boston for its unmistakable…
Continue reading
Sharing is Good: Building a Sharing Economy

Sharing is Good: Building a Sharing Economy & Community

by Beth Buczynski. By changing our idea of what it means to be sustainable people, families, and businesses, and working together…
Continue reading
Climate Change up Close & Personal

Climate Change Up Close & Personal

If you’ve ever wondered how much little things really matter, consider the mountain pine beetle. Roughly the size of a grain of…
Continue reading
What They Don't Know...Could Hurt Us

What They Don't Know...Could Hurt Us

by Stacie Bland. As a high school student, I have seen environmental apathy everywhere. The basic concept among my peers seemed…
Continue reading
Piven’s Theory Of Disruptive Power

Fast or Slow Reform: Frances Fox Piven’s Theory of Disruptive Power

Mostly, the work of social change is a slow process. It involves patiently building movement institutions, cultivating…
Continue reading
Three Simple Reasons Why Climate Change Is Real, And Humans Are Causing it

Three Reasons Why Climate Change Is Real, And Humans Are Causing it

Dire warnings of imminent human-induced climate disaster are constantly in the news but predictions of the end of the world have…
Continue reading
Children of the Millenium: Catalyst for Change

The Children of the Millennium Are A Catalyst for Change

by Edward F. Malkowski. Today’s youth are so civic minded that some social commentators have dubbed them the “civic generation.”…
Continue reading
Seasons Are Changing But Long-term Effects On Wildlife Still Unclear

Seasons Are Changing But Long-Term Effects on Wildlife Still Unclear

Spring and summer have come early – and observations from some parts of the country even suggest that typical autumn events, such…
Continue reading
Another Example Why Big Business Promises Of Cheaper Prices Is Just A Scam

Why Big Business Promises Of Cheaper Prices Is Just A Scam

In Missouri thousands of independent small and mid-size family hog farmers have gone out of business because they don’t have…
Continue reading
Restoring A Sense of Harmony and Balance by Reclaiming Our Sacred Heritage

Restoring Harmony and Balance by Reclaiming Our Sacred Heritage

by Sharron Rose. It is time to start a revolution and envision a new society — a sacred society that arises from a real desire…
Continue reading
Putting Love into the Matrix: Writing New Stories for Society

Putting Love into the Matrix: Writing New Stories for Society

by Carl Greer PhD, PsyD. We worry about the condition of the world we will leave to our children, while our children worry about…
Continue reading
How Many Wolves On The Head Of A Pin?

How Many Wolves Can You Fit On The Head Of A Pin?

About 300 wolves live in the nearly 2-million-acre swath of central Ontario forest known as Algonquin Provincial Park. These…
Continue reading
Solving The Climate Problem by Encouraging The Free Market to be Altruistic

Solving The Climate Problem by Encouraging The Free Market to be Altruistic

The UK government’s senior adviser on science has made an entirely sensible call for researchers and policy makers to move the…
Continue reading
How To Save Equal Access on the Internet

How To Save Equal Access on the Internet

Publicly owned networks in cities across the US preserve net neutrality and provide quality service. With the announcement by the…
Continue reading
How Grassroots Organizing Came To The Rescue In West Virginia’s Water Crisis

Environmentalism's Benefits On Display

An estimated 10,000 gallons of the coal-processing chemical MCHM, along with an unknown amount of a second substance called PPH,…
Continue reading
Eyes of the Future: I dream things that never were; and I say ‘Why not?"

Eyes of the Future: I dream things that never were and I say ‘Why not?"

by Bill Plotkin. Lack of personal meaning and fulfillment is endemic to contemporary Western and Westernized societies. Why are…
Continue reading
canden community garden

Taking Back The Streets One Community Garden At A Time

Meet the tenacious gardeners putting down roots in "America's most desperate town". They're not always optimistic about the…
Continue reading
Banned in Europe But Safe in the U.S.?

Banned in Europe But Safe in the U.S.A.?

Who determines whether chemicals are safe — and why do different governments come up with such different answers? In the United…
Continue reading
Once You Know, There’s No Excuse

Once You Know, There’s No Excuse

“What’s the most effective way to raise awareness of environmental issues and motivate people to take action?” While pondering…
Continue reading
12 Agrihoods That Are Building Sustainable Communities

12 Agrihoods That Are Building Sustainable Communities

Ever wish you could live at your CSA? Or move to a neighborhood where everyone is as excited about fresh, healthy food as you…
Continue reading
Draft Overcomming Greed, Ill-will And Delusion In Our Institutions

Overcoming Greed, Ill-Will and Delusion In Our Institutions

All institutions are the mirror image of the motivations that make them work. So when politics and economics are based on the…
Continue reading
Germany Is Even Out In Front On Renewable Power Tourism

Planning a Vacation? Germany Offers "Renewable Energy Tourism"

A guidebook with a difference is selling well in Germany. It details nearly 200 renewable energy sites it thinks will appeal to…
Continue reading
Should We Fight The System Or Be The Change?

Should We Fight The System or Be The Change?

It is an old question in social movements: Should we fight the system or “be the change we wish to see”? Should we push for…
Continue reading
Protecting The Gray Wolf  In California

Protecting The Gray Wolf as An Endangered Species

The California Fish and Game Commission voted on June 4 to grant endangered species protections to gray wolves. This is the first…
Continue reading

every-moment-of-life-is-an-initiation-the-journey-as-a-cocoon-to-butterfly by Simran Singh. Every situation in life has been an initiation—the leap forward, an activation; the reconciliation and clearing, the integration; and...Read More
who-is-in-charge-you-or-chocolate by William Fergus Martin. Many of us do things we wish we would not do. We may compulsively eat sugary or fatty things, drink too much alcohol, become a...Read More
embracing-new-life-allowing-your-creative-intuitive-power-to-lead-and-support-you by Simone Wright. I invite you to promise yourself that, from this moment forward, you will pursue with power and confidence every dream or desire you...Read More
love-holds-no-grievances by Joyce Vissell. I like the anonymous quote, “Holding resentment is like drinking poison and expecting the other person to die.” This poison can...Read More
coping-with-loss-the-many-faces-of-grief by Echo Bodine. We all deal with grief in our own way. Many turn to addictions like shopping, gambling, hoarding, alcohol, drugs, eating, and even...Read More
awakening-to-the-good-and-to-a-deep-sense-of-oneness by Ervin Laszlo. If we can choose the way we act, we have the responsibility to choose it wisely. Evidently, we can act to maximize our own...Read More
good-enough-to-be-true by Alan Cohen. When I began to teach classes on spiritual principles, I devoted time at the end of each class to pray for students and their loved ones....Read More
the-art-of-encouragement-how-to-encourage-yourself-others: The Art of Encouragement: by Mark Nepo. In many ways, to encourage is to help the heart unfold. And each time we do so, another aspect of our true self...Read More
horoscope-current-week-by-pam-younghans by Pam Younghans. This weekly astrological journal is based on planetary influences, and offers perspectives and insights to assist you in making the...Read More
innerself-newsletter-07-20-2014 We all have habits of some kind. The first step to moving past our habits is to connect with The Joy of Non-Attachment. Then of course, we can replace...Read More
soaked by Kurt Koontz. If Noah were alive, this would have been a nice day to bring the ark out of retirement... I woke up early and started walking in the...Read More
perfectly-imperfect-connections-the-joy-of-nonattachment by Susan L. Westbrook, PhD. The first step to connection is to open ourselves to the possibility that we can survive the hurts and failures that...Read More