Men & Divorce

Ellie Wymard, Ph.D.

The lonely withdrawal from married life is very real to men. They express loss in a million different ways. Some men are without solace, barely able to function, and say that "divorce is worse than death!" The other extreme is evidenced by men who rage rather than mourn. They endure their pain by working longer hours, overindulging in alcohol, or by engaging in frenetic sex or death-defying sporting activities. To show strength, they hide their grief, even from themselves.

Most ex-husbands express their grief somewhere between these polarities. But it is common for all of them, at some point, to feel desolate because loss is an inevitable consequence of divorce.

If a man has been successful
solving problems in his job
but can't control his marriage,
he's thrown by it.

Anyone who has mourned the death of a spouse may not appreciate the comparison, but death and divorce share similarities. Any experience of loss, regardless of what it is, carries with it similar issues that need to be resolved. In general, the problems of loss include forsaking the camaraderie, companionship, understanding, and compassion of a particular person, and accommodating the loneliness that ensues from separation. Feelings of anger, anguish, confusion, and sadness also need to be worked through. Even men who accept divorce as the best answer for their unhappy marriages confront the ultimate questions that death poses: "Who am I now? What did it all mean? Where am I going?"

Divorce vs. Death

According to bereavement experts, when a man's wife dies, the mourning husband will come to the other side, and ultimately say, "She is dead and is not coming back". But when it comes to divorce, certain aspects of loss become slightly magnified. Cathleen Fanslow Brunjes, Bereavement Coordinator' for Hospice Care of Long Island, New York, made the distinction by saying,"Bear in mind that with divorce there's not a body to mourn. It's disenfranchised grief.

"The attendant rituals are missing: there's no wake or funeral. The day the divorce is finalized may pass unnoticed. Family and friends aren't bringing food and casseroles. From society's viewpoint, you couldn't make the marriage work, or you weren't right together anyway. So expressions of grief are somehow unacceptable. Friends grow impatient. If a man has been successful solving problems in his job but can't control his marriage, he's thrown by it. All this works against a man when he feels inside that he has a lot to cry about."

Husbands who are betrayed frequently claim that a wife's death would have been easier to absorb than the reality of her leaving for another man or in search of freedom. Douglas Gillette, co-author of "King, Warrior, Magician, Lover", commented, "When a man is voted against — when his sexuality, capacity to protect, provide, excite is found wanting — it's a disastrous blow to self-worth. Men feel abandoned. There's no other message when a wife leaves a husband."

Men have resisted their grief
because it has made them feel
fragile, unstable, and out of control.

When ex-husbands drag through the day, lack concentration, lose or gain weight, suffer insomnia or crave sleep, and feel guilt followed by anger, they are experiencing the normal symptoms of grief. When divorced men describe feeling emptiness, loneliness, nothingness, and fear that they are going crazy, losing it, or having a nervous breakdown, therapists agree that they are consumed by grief. The best prescription is to go through the hurt, and understand why it is there.

Grief & Divorce

In addition to exploring the unconscious in order to explain the grief of an abandoned husband, therapists also interpret grief within a situational and cultural context. For example, among husbands immobilized after divorce are those who have been taken care of by their wives almost as if they were little boys. In this childlike position, they turn wives into mothers, and are passive while their "mothers" wait on them. For most couples, this behavior is not the result of a rational decision. The comfort of being tended to is seductive, and wives are slow to see the web they are creating.

Until separation forces them to face how dependent they have been on their wives for daily maintenance, encouragement, and understanding, men generally think they are self-reliant. Regardless of how good or bad the marriage was, many of the ex-husbands I interviewed have described feeling "paralyzed" or "numb," "as if I had a leg cut off." Even in a marriage with sparse communication, a husband's support system is often dismantled when the marriage ends and he is on his own.

Grief is a natural, if unexpected, part of the divorce process, but men, in general, are surprised by the force of its demands. Buried deep in our society's subconscious is the stoical image of John Wayne, callous to sadness and heartbreak. While therapists concur that grief is ultimately cured alone, a man moving through divorce often thinks that no one else has ever felt the way he does. At some point in the divorce cycle, a man will feel bereft, helpless, and desolate. But if he silences these feelings, other men have also silenced them. If he feels guilt and embarrassment, so have other men. If he is scared by his confusion, other men have also known that fear.

Grief is not madness, but ex-husbands often endure it as a shameful secret. Grief is so mistaken as a sign of weakness that men have aborted mourning by expressing anger and hostility, emotions natural to separation and divorce, but more "acceptable" for men to vent than sorrow. Finding it easier to verbalize anger than grief, they blame their wives or themselves for causing the marriage to fail.

Role Expectations

In the past 30 years, taboos have relaxed about what is acceptable for a woman to express about her inner life. Not so with men. Men have resisted their grief because it has made them feel fragile, unstable, and out of control. They have feared that their symptoms were pathological, when, indeed, they are to be expected. If men bury their grief, it will only overwhelm them at another time. Role expectations therefore complicate a man's behavioral response to grief in a way not generally experienced by women.

Bereavement experts have, therefore, suggested to me that a divorced man can be reassured that he is not different from other men, and yet is recognizable as himself, if he understands the stages of bereavement. Once he accepts the fact that grief is a normal emotional response to the irretrievable loss of another person, he may gain insight into the range of emotions he is feeling and find solace in knowing that others have been where he is.


RelationshipsThis article was excerpted from 

Men on Divorce - Conversations With Ex-Husbands
by Ellie Wymard.

Excerpted with permission from the publisher. ©1994. Published by Hay House, www.hayhouse.com.

Info/Order this book


Ellie Wymard, Ph.D.About The Author

Ellie Wymard, Ph.D. is the director of the Master of Fine Arts program and a professor of English at Carlow University in Pittsburgh, as well as a national television and radio personality. She is also the author of Talking Steel Towns: The Women and Men of America's Steel Valley; Conversations With Uncommon Women: Insights from women who've risen above life's challenges to achieve extraordinary success; Men On Divorce; and Divorced Women, New Lives.     (More info on this author)


 

Enjoyed this article? Share with your friends...

Relationships

The Art of Encouragement: How to Encourage Yourself & Others

How to Encourage Yourself & Others: The Art of Encouragement

: The Art of Encouragement: by Mark Nepo. In many ways, to encourage is to help the heart unfold. And each time we do so, another…
Continue reading
Perfectly Imperfect Connections: The Joy of NonAttachment

Perfectly Imperfect Connections: The Joy of NonAttachment

by Susan L. Westbrook, PhD. The first step to connection is to open ourselves to the possibility that we can survive the hurts…
Continue reading
Becoming Your Own Best Friend: One of the Secrets of a Happy Life

One of the Secrets of a Happy Life is to Become Your Own Best Friend

by Barbara Berger. One of the secrets of living a happy life is to become your own best friend. But you can only do this when you…
Continue reading
Love Holds No Grievances: Choosing Peace in Relatinships

Love Holds No Grievances: Choosing Peace in Relationships

by Joyce Vissell. I like the anonymous quote, “Holding resentment is like drinking poison and expecting the other person to die.”…
Continue reading
Birthday Tradition: Redefining the  Great American Ritual

Birthday Tradition: Redefining the Great American Ritual

by Patricia Cohen. Almost any culture from which we originated had traditions or rites of passage that symbolized the changing…
Continue reading
Awakening to “The Good” and to a Deep Sense of Oneness

Awakening to “The Good” and to a Deep Sense of Oneness

by Ervin Laszlo. If we can choose the way we act, we have the responsibility to choose it wisely. Evidently, we can act to…
Continue reading
Should I Get A Divorce? Steps To A Happy Marriage

Should I Get A Divorce? Three Steps To A Happy Marriage

by Joseph Murphy. Divorce is an individual problem. It cannot be generalized. In some cases, divorce is not the solution, no more…
Continue reading
The Secret Formula To Successful Online Dating

The Secret Formula To Successful Online Dating

According to recent surveys, more than 40m single people out of 54m singles in the US have signed up to an online dating site…
Continue reading
Looking Inside Yourself For Definitive Answers with Relationship Therapy

Looking Inside Yourself For Definitive Answers: Relationship Therapy

by Kelly Johnson, M.D. Is relationship therapy really needed? Why can't most of us just wing it and hope that everything turns…
Continue reading
We've Been Limiting the Love We Get by Limiting the Love We Give!

We've Been Limiting the Love We Get by Limiting the Love We Give!

by Sandy C. Newbigging. Love is the essence of your being. Love is what you are. It is not something you get depending on what…
Continue reading
Cause and Effect: Depression in Children and Teens

Cause and Effect of Mixed Messages: Depression in Children and Teens

by Francesca Cappucci Fordyce. Children diagnosed with severe behavioral problems are blamed for their bad conduct. Yet parents…
Continue reading
Let Someone Into Your Heart

Let Someone Into Your Heart

by Alan Cohen. Most of us have at some time thought or said, "I will never love again." In the wake of emotional pain, it is…
Continue reading
Being Angels to One Another and Making Love Multiply

Being Angels to One Another and Making Love Multiply

by Dawna Markova. Making a loaf of Sabbath bread on Friday morning was my grandmother's favorite teaching tool. As she kneaded…
Continue reading
How Teachers Transform Classrooms With Emotional Learning

Unleashing Empathy: How Teachers Transform Classrooms through Emotional Learning

The secret to learning self-awareness, cooperation, and other “social and emotional learning” skills lies in experience, not in…
Continue reading
Leaders and Helpers: Learning Through Our Differences and Our Similarities

Leaders and Helpers: Learning Through Our Differences and Similarities

by J.T. Garrett and Michael Tlanusta Garrett. Quite possibly, it is through our differences that we learn the true value of that…
Continue reading
Men and Women Feel Things Differently: Guts and Hearts

Men and Women Feel Things Differently: Guts and Hearts

by David Kundtz. Many studies have shown that women's brains are wired differently from men's so they can both feel and recall…
Continue reading
Harvesting the Fruits & Gifts of Solitude

Harvesting the Fruits & Gifts of Solitude

by Zenith Henkin Gross. Americans are deeply ambivalent about the solitary person in our midst. On the one hand, the lone hero is…
Continue reading
Night Owls Are Less Likely To Get Married

Night Owls Are Less Likely To Get Married

People who tend to stay up late and wake up late in the morning are different in many important ways from early risers, new…
Continue reading
From Repression to Transcendence: Is There Life After Sex?

From Repression to Transcendence: Is There Life After Sex?

by Osho. You exist as a sexual being. Once you accept it, the conflict that has been created down through the centuries…
Continue reading
Appreciating Your Partner & Being Mindful of Each Other

Appreciating Your Partner and Being Mindful of Each Other

by Susan K. Perry, Ph.D. Do the best couples have any secret strategies for staying mindful and not taking one another for…
Continue reading
Why Do Opposites Repel or at Other Times Attract?

Why Do Opposites Repel or at Other Times Attract?

by Shakti Gawain. The people in our lives who make us uncomfortable, who annoy us, who we feel judgmental or even combative…
Continue reading
It's Not Your Job as a Parent to Make Your Children Happy

It's Not Your Job as a Parent to Make Your Children Happy

by Barbara Berger. Sitting with clients every day makes me realize that so many people are confused when it comes to the…
Continue reading
Is It Closeness … or Codependence?

Is It Closeness … or Codependence?

by Barry Vissell. When we were in our twenties, Joyce and I were criticized for being too close. Some people even quoted Kahlil…
Continue reading
Love problems? There’s a pill for that, but Plato offers a wiser cure

There’s A Pill For Love Problems, Or Maybe Not

Is pill-popping the best way to ensure we stay in love with our long-term partner? Should we also pop a pill to try to fall out…
Continue reading
Can Love Make You Whole? Discovering the Sacred Connection

Can Love Make You Whole? Discovering the Sacred Connection

by Julie Tallard Johnson. Unfortunately, many of us get lost on our way to find wholeness and happiness — we get lost in search…
Continue reading
Living From Your Heart

Living From Your Heart & Welcoming Everyone with Love

by Caroline Sutherland. In order to reach the summit of your own personal mountain, your mandate must be to love, inspire, and…
Continue reading

every-moment-of-life-is-an-initiation-the-journey-as-a-cocoon-to-butterfly by Simran Singh. Every situation in life has been an initiation—the leap forward, an activation; the reconciliation and clearing, the integration; and...Read More
who-is-in-charge-you-or-chocolate by William Fergus Martin. Many of us do things we wish we would not do. We may compulsively eat sugary or fatty things, drink too much alcohol, become a...Read More
love-holds-no-grievances by Joyce Vissell. I like the anonymous quote, “Holding resentment is like drinking poison and expecting the other person to die.” This poison can...Read More
coping-with-loss-the-many-faces-of-grief by Echo Bodine. We all deal with grief in our own way. Many turn to addictions like shopping, gambling, hoarding, alcohol, drugs, eating, and even...Read More
embracing-new-life-allowing-your-creative-intuitive-power-to-lead-and-support-you by Simone Wright. I invite you to promise yourself that, from this moment forward, you will pursue with power and confidence every dream or desire you...Read More
awakening-to-the-good-and-to-a-deep-sense-of-oneness by Ervin Laszlo. If we can choose the way we act, we have the responsibility to choose it wisely. Evidently, we can act to maximize our own...Read More
good-enough-to-be-true by Alan Cohen. When I began to teach classes on spiritual principles, I devoted time at the end of each class to pray for students and their loved ones....Read More
the-art-of-encouragement-how-to-encourage-yourself-others: The Art of Encouragement: by Mark Nepo. In many ways, to encourage is to help the heart unfold. And each time we do so, another aspect of our true self...Read More
horoscope-current-week-by-pam-younghans by Pam Younghans. This weekly astrological journal is based on planetary influences, and offers perspectives and insights to assist you in making the...Read More
innerself-newsletter-07-20-2014 We all have habits of some kind. The first step to moving past our habits is to connect with The Joy of Non-Attachment. Then of course, we can replace...Read More
soaked by Kurt Koontz. If Noah were alive, this would have been a nice day to bring the ark out of retirement... I woke up early and started walking in the...Read More
perfectly-imperfect-connections-the-joy-of-nonattachment by Susan L. Westbrook, PhD. The first step to connection is to open ourselves to the possibility that we can survive the hurts and failures that...Read More